My son,
You will be told a thousand lies about what a man is. Start by doubting the loudest voices.
The loudest voices will not always sound angry. Some of them will sound confident. Some will sound successful. Some will sound like discipline, like toughness, like nobody can hurt me. They will tell you a man should never need too much, never feel too much, never ask too much, never soften first.
I believed parts of that before I knew I believed them.
I learned early that boys are always being watched. Not always by adults. Sometimes by other boys. Sometimes by the room itself. You learn what gets laughed at. You learn what gets respected. You learn which feelings make people uncomfortable. You learn that anger is easier to explain than sadness, and silence is safer than need.
That kind of learning can happen without anyone sitting you down and teaching it. It gets into you by repetition. A joke lands. A soft moment gets punished. A boy admits too much and the room turns on him. So you start editing yourself before anybody else can.
I do not want to pretend I was above that.
There were times I made myself harder than I was. Times I acted like I did not care because caring felt dangerous. Times I used distance as armor. Times I confused being difficult to reach with being strong.
There were also times I participated in the same thing that hurt me. That is the part men do not like to admit. It is easier to say the world taught us badly than to say we helped enforce the lesson on someone else.
I have laughed when I should have protected. I have gone quiet when someone needed me to speak. I have mistaken tenderness for weakness in another person because I was afraid of recognizing it in myself.
That is not manhood. That is fear trying to win approval.
The world will offer you many costumes. Tough guy. Provider. Winner. Alpha. Rebel. Nice guy. Strong silent type. The costumes change, but the trick is the same. They ask you to trade your whole self for a version of yourself people can understand quickly.
Do not make that trade.
You do not have to be loud to be strong. You do not have to be hard to be safe. You do not have to dominate a room to belong in it.
Real strength is quieter than I thought when I was young. It looks like telling the truth when a lie would protect your image. It looks like apologizing without performing your shame. It looks like staying present when your first instinct is to disappear. It looks like holding power carefully because you know what power can do in careless hands.
There will be moments when you are tested.
Not by dramatic battles. By small invitations.
Someone will be mocked in front of you. You will feel the room waiting to see whether you join in.
Someone will tell you something vulnerable. You will feel the temptation to make it lighter because their honesty makes you uncomfortable.
Someone will love you enough to tell you that you hurt them. You will feel your pride rise up with a lawyer in its mouth.
Those are the moments that shape a man.
Not the quotes he posts. Not the image he sells. Not the way he talks when everyone already agrees with him.
The man is revealed when he can choose between protection and performance.
I hope you choose protection.
Protect the person who is not powerful in the room. Protect the truth when it costs you approval. Protect your own softness from people who would rather you become easy to categorize than fully alive.
But protection does not mean pretending you are harmless. You will have anger. You will have ambition. You will have strength in you that needs direction. I do not want you to be ashamed of that. A man without force can become passive. A man ruled by force can become dangerous. The work is learning how to carry force without letting it carry you.
That is where many men fail. They think the goal is to have no fear, so they hide fear until it comes out sideways. They think the goal is to have no need, so they make the people who love them guess. They think the goal is to never look small, so they become too proud to repair anything they break.
I want better for you.
If you are scared, say you are scared before fear becomes cruelty.
If you are lonely, say you are lonely before loneliness becomes resentment.
If you are wrong, say you are wrong before pride builds a house around the mistake.
I am still learning this. I still have old scripts in me. I still feel the pull to grip tighter, speak sharper, go colder, prove more. The difference is that I do not want to call those instincts manhood anymore.
I want you to know earlier than I did that tenderness is not the opposite of strength. It is one of the ways strength proves it is safe.
A weak man can be loud. A frightened man can be hard. A wounded man can call control leadership. None of that makes him whole.
Wholeness is harder.
It means telling the truth about what hurt you without making your pain everyone else's weather. It means letting love reach the places you learned to guard. It means becoming responsible for your impact, not just proud of your intention.
So if the world tells you to become less human so you can be more of a man, do not believe it.
Become honest.
Become steady.
Become brave enough to be soft where softness is called for and firm where firmness is required.
Become the kind of man a child can relax around. The kind of man a woman does not have to shrink beside. The kind of man whose friends can tell him the truth without fearing his pride.
That is the kind of man I am trying to become for you.
And if I ever forget, I hope you will have seen enough repair in me to know that the loudest version of your father was not always the truest one.
~ Dad
First Man in the Line
Previous letter | Start here | All letters | Next letter
Get the Saturday letter
Read the next First Man in the Line letter in your inbox each Saturday morning.
Subscribe for the Saturday letter
This draft stays inside the First Man in the Line literary sequence by Anthony A. Luna.